Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Why do American movies glorify genocide?

American movies glorify the genocide that was commited against the Native American people by settlers. Films like ones starring John Wayne prtray the Natives almost as animals and show the perpretators of the genocide as gallant cowboys and heroes. In reality the Native Americans were defending their homelands and their famillies against foreign invaders and were the victims. These movies are no different than the mocvies made by Nazi Germany to dehumanise the Jews and to justify the persecution of the Jews. Many of these 'Cowboy and Indian' movies glorifying this genocide would have made Joeseph Goebbels prowd. Why do Americans enjoy watching this propaganda?Why do American movies glorify genocide?The Native people were in the way and needed to be removed??? Is that the best excuse for genocide??the US government killed more Native Americans than the Nazis killed Jews. the movie i think you are referring to did make me not like John Wayne for quite a long time. but you do have to remember that those types of movies were produced in the "White is Right" era in our history.they could not be made now.Why do American movies glorify genocide?
It's the same thing. I teach in a high school and can show any movie with glorified violence, but nothing with nudity. That even means I can't show Roots.Why do American movies glorify genocide?There are also movies glorifying slavery but we don't throw them in a bonfire and burn them. It is part of this countrys history we can't just forget about it. A movie is just a movie.
OK, Americans today do not enjoy watching cowboy and Indian movies. Maybe a long time ago they were popular, but not today. Those movies are propaganda, they tell one side of a story and portray us as defenders, rather than what we were, invaders. Furthermore, the portrayal of Indians as savages is incorrect, they were fierce warriors, but not savages. You never see the battles that they won in those movies.Why do American movies glorify genocide?These movies portray a time when America was expanding. The native population was in the way and needed to be removed. Sometime by treaty, sometime by force. We can all be thankful that the Americans won those conflicts. The idea of living a nomadic life with primitive technology has no appeal. These films are not propaganda but a positive portrayal of a time when little thought was given to the welfare of ones enemy. To think you could somehow equate the founding of our nation with the Nazi regime tells me you are in need of serious helpWhy do American movies glorify genocide?
Because most people didn't know any better. You are correct that movies such as those were born from propaganda and lies. A huge engine for movies such as those were the Buffalo Bill Wild West Shows. These shows, while sometimes portraying the plight of Indians to the general public, also served to perpetuate stereotypes, and present the natives as a "lost" or "vanishing" race. These were the first "cowboy and Indian" movies.



My university requires an ethnic studies course and that is the only reason I know anything at all about Native American history. I learned very little about real Native American history in grade / high school.
Well, the Indians weren't Boy Scouts, either. They would gladly have done the same to the European colonists, but they weren't as organized, didn't have the military technology, and after they were decimated by European diseases, they didn't have the numbers.



Let's not get all teary eyed about the fiction of peaceful savages.Why do American movies glorify genocide?
Goldenrae teaches children? I fear for the future.
  • p411
  • alpinestars
  • No comments:

    Post a Comment